Tools
How to pick a first colored pencil set
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We earn a commission if you buy through the links marked “paid link” on this site. It doesn’t change what we recommend. Prices and availability are set by Amazon and change often.
The short answer
A 24-color student-grade set is a reasonable first tin for an adult coloring book. You mix more hues by layering than by owning more pencils. An artist-grade set can feel creamier or hold a point longer, depending on the core, but it will not teach light pressure, a short palette, or a test swatch any faster. If you already own a set you like, use that and spend the money on a book and a sharpener instead.
Start with 24 colors, not 72
Twenty-four colors cover a warm and a cool version of the main hues, plus a few browns and a dark. That is enough to shade, to mix a secondary, and to keep a first page from becoming a catalog of every stick in the tin. A larger set, such as the Castle Art Supplies 72 for adults(paid link), is useful only if you already have it or already know you want a wide range. It is not a better teacher. Our colored pencil guide goes into brands and counts in more detail; this page is only about choosing a first tin you will actually use.
Student-grade and artist-grade
Student-grade pencils are usually cheaper per stick and are made for practice and school or hobby use. Artist-grade pencils are usually made with a higher pigment load and a core that is meant to layer further or to keep a point longer. Those are manufacturer and catalog distinctions, not a promise that one page will look “professional.”
In this guide the student example is the Prismacolor Scholar set of 24(paid link), and the artist-grade example in the same family is the Prismacolor Premier Soft Core set of 24(paid link). We have not used either set hands-on yet. If you are buying a first tin and want to start simply, the Scholar 24 is the more modest starting point we list.
Softer wax-based and firmer oil-based cores
Many popular adult-coloring pencils are described as wax-based and relatively soft: they can lay down a lot of color with little pressure, which helps with creamy blends, and they can also mush or break more easily and, over time, show wax bloom. Firmer, often oil-based pencils, such as the Faber-Castell Polychromos tin of 24(paid link), are widely described as holding a point longer and as being less prone to wax bloom, though they may take more layers to look fully filled. Either type will work in a coloring book if you stay light at the start. You can also mix brands on one page: it usually works well to use the firmer pencil first and the softer one later.
A simple way to decide
- Use what you already own, if it will mark the page. A first adult coloring page is about light pressure and a test swatch, not about the logo on the barrel. See start your first adult coloring page.
- If you are buying, choose a 24-color set in one family. The Scholar 24 is the modest starting point we list. Step up to the Premier 24 or a Polychromos 24 later if you already know you want a softer or a firmer artist-grade core.
- Budget for a sharpener you trust, not for more colors. A long-point hand sharpener, such as the KUM Long Point(paid link), matters more on a detailed page than a second tin you will not finish.
- Do not buy a water-soluble tin as your only first set unless you already want a wet technique. Inktense and traditional watercolor pencils need tighter water control on book paper. Read those guides first, and practice on watercolor paper, before you put water on a design you care about.
Common mistakes
- Buying 72 colors before you have finished a first page. Extra sticks do not replace light layers or a test corner.
- Assuming “artist-grade” will hide heavy pressure. A soft core will still shine, indent, and fill the tooth if you press hard on the first pass.
- Choosing only by the picture on the tin. Read the count, the core type if it is stated, and whether the set is sold for adults. Then test on scrap or a swatch before you commit a book page.
- Throwing out a student set the day you buy an artist tin. The firmer or cheaper stick is still useful for underlayers and for tight edges.
Watch the video
This written guide is the companion to our video on how to pick a first colored pencil set. When that video is published, it will be embedded here. We will not add a link or a player until the video exists.
No video is available yet.
Questions
Is a student set “good enough” for an adult coloring book?
Yes, for learning the habits that actually show on the page: light pressure, a short palette, and a test swatch. You can always step up later.
Should I start with Prismacolor or Polychromos?
There is no single right answer. If you want a softer, creamier core in a brand we already list, the Premier 24 is the artist-grade example in the Prismacolor family. If you want a firmer point, the Polychromos 24 is the example we list. We have not used either set hands-on yet, so treat that as a starting map, not a review.
Can I mix a student pencil and an artist pencil on the same page?
Yes. If one core is much softer than the other, use the firmer pencil first and the softer one later.
Sets mentioned in this guide
These are the listings we already researched for this guide. There are no prices on this page. We have not used these sets hands-on yet.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We earn a commission if you buy through the links marked “paid link” on this site. It doesn’t change what we recommend. Prices and availability are set by Amazon and change often.
Prismacolor Scholar, 24 colors
Listing title: Prismacolor Scholar Colored Pencils, Assorted Colors, 24 Count | For Beginner Artists, Vibrant Colors, Strong Cores Minimize Breakage, Drawing, Blending, Shading, Art Supplies for Students · ASIN B0G7L9S3YZ
A student-grade wax-based set in a 24-color count. Our modest starting point for a first adult coloring book if you are buying a tin. This card is for the current 24-color listing (the page labels it “24 Count (New Packaging)”). We have not used this set hands-on yet. Check the count and the packaging name on the listing before you buy; other counts are sold as different options.
- Good for
- Adults buying a first set who want enough colors to mix on the page without a large artist tin.
- Skip if
- You already have a set you like, or you already know you want an artist-grade pencil.
See the current price on Amazon(paid link)
Prismacolor Premier Soft Core, 24 colors
Listing title: Prismacolor Premier Colored Pencils, Soft Core, Assorted Colors, 24 Count · ASIN B00006IEEU
An artist-grade wax-based set in the same 24-color count as the Scholar set above. Softer than a student-grade core, so it can feel creamier and may layer further. We have not used this set hands-on yet.
- Good for
- Adults who already know they want a softer artist-grade pencil, or who are ready to step up from a student set.
- Skip if
- You are buying a first tin and want to start simply; the Scholar 24 is the more modest starting point in this guide.
See the current price on Amazon(paid link)
Faber-Castell Polychromos, tin of 24
Listing title: Faber-Castell Polychromos Artists' Color Pencils - Tin of 24 Colors - Premium Quality Artist Pencils · ASIN B0007OECK8
A 24-color tin of Polychromos artist pencils. These are widely described as a firmer, oil-based core that holds a point longer and is less prone to wax bloom than a soft wax pencil, though they may take more layers to look fully filled. We have not used this set hands-on yet.
- Good for
- Adults who want a firmer point for detailed line work, or who already know they prefer this type of core.
- Skip if
- You want a very soft, creamy laydown as your first artist-grade set, or you only need a student tin to begin.
See the current price on Amazon(paid link)
Castle Art Supplies 72 for adults
Listing title: Castle Art Supplies 72 Colored Pencils for Adults - Soft Core Leads · ASIN B06ZZNF7GS
A 72-color soft-core set sold for adults. We list it only to say that you do not need 72 colors to learn a first page or a first shaded shape. We have not used this set hands-on yet.
- Good for
- Adults who already have this set, or who already know they want a wide range.
- Skip if
- You are buying a first tin; a 24-color set is enough.
See the current price on Amazon(paid link)
KUM Long Point sharpener
Listing title: KUM Long Point Pencil Sharpener with Lead Pointer · ASIN B0084F7I1C
A hand sharpener with two holes: one cuts back the wood, the other shapes a long point on the core. Worth planning for when you buy a first tin, especially with softer pencils.
- Good for
- Keeping a clean point for detailed pages and for soft cores that break in ordinary sharpeners.
- Skip if
- You already have a sharpener you trust.
See the current price on Amazon(paid link)
Related guides
For a longer brand-by-brand overview, see how to choose colored pencils. For using the tin on a first page, see start your first adult coloring page. For shading and for blending, see how to shade an adult coloring page and how to blend colored pencils smoothly.